Conversation
It’s a Match!
Pietro Bianchi and Karina Pawlow on (Im)material Objects
Organized by Rebecca Carrai and the Lise Meitner Group "Coded Objects"
Rather than lectures, this event series is a staged conversation, clash or celebration of two people with two distinct positions. Sometimes a blind date, sometimes a fierce competition, sometimes a surprising counterpart, or the perfect fit, in these matches the two speakers will first each present their perspective on a given theme or project, to then discuss divergences or conflations with the audience. From fiery disagreements to harmonious affirmations, the conversation series organized by the Lise Meitner Group “Coded Objects” aims to refract perspectives on historical narratives as well as reconstruct creative processes. In the third session, theorist Pietro Bianchi and art historian Karina Pawlow, who recently joined the Lise Meitner Group, will discuss (im)material objects in their respective research.
Pietro Bianchi will reflect on what is a commodity and how it differs from any empirical object we have before our eyes. In what he termed the fetish-character of a commodity, Marx contrasts the “immediate” and concrete nature of a commodity or object—perceived exactly as it appears to us in its sensible features—with its complex social and economic mediations, which remain invisible and absent from its immediate presentation. As is evident from Eisenstein’s 1928 notes on his unrealized film project on Das Kapital—recently analyzed in Alexander Kluge’s nine-hour-long film essay News from Ideological Antiquity—the Marxian notion of commodity fetishism addresses a compelling relationship between visibility and invisibility (and between immediacy and mediation). From Eisenstein’s and Kluge’s reflections, we can deduce that if material objects, as we perceive them, are in their concreteness—or through their concreteness—an erasure of their social dimension, it is because, in the visual realm—which Bianchi argues is the realm of commodity fetishism—we can see only what is immediately in front of our eyes. Bianchi’s presentation will reflect on what remains inaccessible to our vision, which is what Fredric Jameson in another context called “cognitive mapping”: the invisible (yet socially crucial) coexistence of different spaces—finance, production, distribution, and others—that shape our world but remain repressed in our visual and discursive representations.
In her presentation, Karina Pawlow brings us closer to her doctoral research, Patently Clever People, by looking at three rare 16th-century glass plaques featuring relief portraits of Doge Andrea Gritti that showcase a groundbreaking technique patented by Filippo Catanei in 1517. Pawlow retraces the early modern, creative process lying behind such innovation, which enabled the creation of glass ornamenti with a hollow interior and flat exterior, crafted from “glass as hard as marble.” Exemplifying Murano's technical ingenuity, these pieces highlight Venice's patronage of glassmaking and, as Pawlow argues, allow us to grasp the early value placed on intellectual property. Simultaneously, the Gritti busts navigate patrician efforts to limit the doge’s individual authority, circumventing restrictions on solo doge portraits in currency. Derived from medals, these technically novel glass casts exemplify pioneering examples of how to commodify power, showcasing Gritti not only as a symbol of the Serenissima, but also as an influential statesman. Likely displayed in elite private collections, such objects of (im)material values appealed to social and intellectual ambitions while subtly reinforcing Gritti’s legacy.
Democracy in America di Romeo Castellucci, photo: Guido Mencari.
16th-century glass plaque featuring a relief portrait of Doge Andrea Gritti in the British Museum, photo: Karina Pawlow.
Biographical Notes
Pietro Bianchi is an Assistant Professor in English at the University of Florida. He is the author of Jacques Lacan and Cinema: Imaginary, Gaze, Formalisation (Routledge, 2017) and has published articles on film studies, philosophy, critical theory, and psychoanalysis. He also collaborates as a film critic with e-flux, Cineforum, DinamoPress, and Doppiozero.
Karina Pawlow is an art and visual historian, and a doctoral fellow in the Lise Meitner Group “Coded Objects,” where she examines early modern glass drawings as autonomous paper objects and witnesses to investigations of materials and craftsmanship. Her work is situated at the intersection of art history, the history of science, and the history of technology. Before studying art history, Karina held her bachelor’s degree in business administration, which led to her secondary research focus on image-based social media.
11 December 2024, 5:00pm
This event will be hybrid and take place in person at Palazzo Grifoni Budini Gattai. There is no need to formally register to participate in person.
For online participation please register in advance: https://eu02web.zoom-x.de/meeting/register/u5Erf-mhqzwjEtfBoY7qGpi0bPw_u3cshKvI
Notice
This event will be documented photographically and/or recorded on video. Please let us know if you do not agree with the Kunsthistorisches Institut in Florenz using images in which you might be recognizable for event documentation and public relation purposes (e.g. social media).